There’s a big difference between defending your organisation in court and protecting your reputation. And McDonald’s is learning that the hard way.

The fast food giant is once again facing damaging headlines about sexual harassment and a “toxic” workplace culture, with legal actions under way and a fresh BBC report today detailing more disturbing accounts from former employees.

Among them is a young woman who describes an environment where older workers routinely pursue young colleagues for sex and a manager dismissed her concerns about being sexually harassed by customers, telling her to “just suck it up”.

These are serious allegations and McDonald’s has repeatedly said:

“Ensuring a safe, respectful and inclusive working environment remains a fundamental priority.”

But what makes this latest episode striking from a crisis communications perspective is less the allegations than the way McDonald’s has responded.

Court of law v public opinion

Hundreds of current and former McDonald’s employees are now pursuing discrimination cases against the company through the courts.

McDonald’s has tried hard to have the claims struck out, but this week an employment tribunal judge ruled that 450 cases can proceed to a hearing in April.

This ruling is clearly not a finding that McDonald’s has acted unlawfully. That may or may not come later. And a company is obviously free to defend itself against lawsuits using any legal means available.

But there’s a big difference between what a company is legally entitled to do and what makes sense for its reputation.

While trying to stop claims proceeding is a legally predictable and perhaps necessary course of action, it’s not a good look – creating the strong impression that McDonald’s priority is to make the problems go away rather than get to grips with them.

Instead of the conversation focusing on what the company is doing to improve, it’s again put the spotlight on whether it’s taking the allegations seriously.

And such issues have never been more in the public consciousness as now in the wake of Russell Brand’s high-profile conviction for rape and sexual assaults and the allegations against David Walliams.

Refusal to discuss the past

This risk of appearing disreputable in this respect is all the more acute as it’s not the first time McDonald’s has been reluctant to address such allegations.

In a BBC interview earlier this year, the company’s recently-appointed UK & Ireland CEO, Lauren Schultz, side-stepped questions about claims from former employees by saying: “I don’t want to talk about the past.” That was something, she said, the company had “drawn a line under.”

I can partly understand the instinct. There’s a common temptation in corporate crises to retreat to a defensive position.

Legal advisers focus on avoiding admissions to protect the company’s position in potential litigation. And, when an organisation has been hit by damaging claims, its leaders naturally want instead to focus on more positive things.

Crisis communications gone awry

But that’s where crisis communications can go awry if the organisation, as in this case, fails to read the room.

Companies need to consider how their behaviour will come across to employees, shareholders, customers, regulators, journalists and the wider public.

Legal and reputational priorities may appear in conflict and this can be a tricky matter to navigate. Yet with the right advice and careful judgement, they can usually be reconciled.

Acknowledging the seriousness of allegations is not the same as admitting legal liability. Expressing concern for employees is not an admission of wrongdoing. And investigating past incidences does not have to mean abandoning your legal defence.

From a reputational point of view, as uncomfortable as it may be, you can’t simply “draw a line under” the past. That’s not within your gift as the rest of the world may remain deeply concerned about it – and it appears like trying to brush your problems under the carpet. You may well have to acknowledge them fully first before you can credibly move the conversation forward.

Complainants need to feel heard. Employees need confidence the organisation truly understands what went wrong. The wider public needs evidence that lessons have been learned.

Where failings have occurred, recognition and apologies are also often essential.

Problematic

In McDonald’s case, a reluctance to address past events is particularly problematic because accusations have consistently dogged the company ever since a BBC investigation in 2023 first reported “a toxic culture of sexual assault, harassment, racism and bullying”, creating the firm impression they are far from behind the company.

McDonald’s may well have introduced meaningful improvements since then. But its communications need to demonstrate not only what it’s changed and the effect it hopes this will have in future, but that it truly understands why those changes are necessary.

The lessons for all of us are clear.

When your reputation is under fire, you need to prove you’ve fully got to grips with what’s happened. An overly defensive response lurking behind clichéd statements can do more reputational damage than the allegations themselves.

 

You can find out here about our crisis communications advice and services.